Longtime readers of my journal might have noticed something–something glaringly different–that I have mentioned in these more recent posts. It’s something that I have struggled with for years (though it didn’t show up as struggle as often as it showed up as judgment): deciding whether or not I wanted to have children.
This is an incredibly tender topic for me to share about, but one that I feel such a dramatic shift around, that I can’t help but want to share the story of how radically this issue has altered my life.
For years now, I have been adamant that I did not want to have children–ever. The biggest reasons for this were twofold:
1.) I felt sure that if I did have children, my “life” would be over. That’s it. No more creative work. No more lazy Saturday mornings. No more throwing money at a sweater or something meaningless when there were diapers to buy. No more sex or intimacy with my partner. I have felt convinced that my life would become nothing but changing diapers and running after screaming children.
2.) I didn’t want to “fuck it up.” This was the phrase I used when I talked to people about it. “I don’t want to have a kid, because I’m pretty sure I’d fuck it up,” I said. I was not always being glib or rough when I said this. For some reason, that phrase “fuck it up” was the most authentic phrase I felt I could use. I walked with a belief that, for sure, if I were to have a child, I would “fuck it up” by yelling at it or not wanting to be as attentive as I should be or somehow passing along all of my flaws, pains, and hurts to that child.
As a result of being so adamant that I did not want kids, I was someone who could not be in a store with a screaming child. If I was out and about and a kid started howling, I’d grab Andy and say “Get me out of here–now.” And when another female friend of mine would get pregnant, I’d think, “Another one bites the dust,” because (unfortunately) it has been my experience that moms want to hang with other moms, people with whom they feel they have more in common. I felt judgmental of women who had kids and then complained about the duties of motherhood. I would then complain to Andy about mothers who complained. “They signed themselves up,” I would tell him in frustration. “God invented birth control for a reason. I’m sick of mothers positing themselves as martyrs just because they had kids.” You know that Sex and the City episode in season six, the one where Carrie’s shoes are stolen and Tatum O’Neal plays her friend who “shoe shames” Carrie? I watched that episode multiple times, always siding with Carrie. I’d felt the energy, too, of parents who believed that being a parent trumped all other cards. More than once, when talking to other parents, Andy and I would be asked what we were up to and if we said something like, “Oh, we got up, went out to breakfast, hit a few bookstores,” we’d get responses like, “Well, wait until you have kids–those days will be over!” I resented this attitude enormously because, it seemed to me, I did not invalidate their choices to have kids, so why were they invalidating my choice to be child-less?
The energy, felt very us/them, very polarized. And I heightened that sense of polarization with my resentment.
(If you are reading any of this and intuiting it as outright hostility, you’d be right–but keep reading).
Alongside this hostility, there were these other experiences that happened here and there. Experiences like:
* A recurring dream. In it, I am riding in the passenger’s seat of a car, at night. We are on the highway, and the orangey highway lights are fading in and out as we pass by them, illuminating things briefly and then fading out, illuminating, fading out. And on my lap there is a baby. She has a head of black hair and these dark eyes. She is wearing a little white t-shirt and a white diaper, and her head is near my knees and her feet are near my belly, and she’s just looking at me, watching me. And in this dream, I feel such a strong love for her, and she’s my baby and I’m just utterly in love with her. And then–I wake up. And over the years of having this dream, when I would wake up and realize that it was a dream and she wasn’t with me in real life, I would cry and cry, just so completely and totally heartbroken that it wasn’t true, that this baby was not my baby, and it had only been a dream.
* Not a dream: In my old chiropractor’s office years ago, a woman who was in extreme pain came in with her baby who was only a few weeks old. The secretary was holding the baby while the mother was being treated, and then all the phone lines were ringing at once, and suddenly I was holding this baby for the secretary. I held her facing outward, so that we were both looking the same direction, out the window. And as I held this little body against mine, and smelled her, and rocked her, it was the kind of simple pleasure that I don’t know I’ve felt under any other circumstances. It was, quite simply, fulfilling.
* I will never forget being 14 and watching my youngest sister being born, the way the entire hospital room was filled with the most beautiful, radiant energy possible, the way my mother and I held each other and cried nakedly at the most extraordinary experience of a new life emerging into the world. And I was the first person to hold my youngest sister, this small little football-sized being who sort of squinted out at the world, sort of like, “Yeah, I’m not so sure about this. But we’ll give it a shot.”
* Feeling a complete thrill when a kid would give me a hug, draw me a picture, or ask to tell me a secret. Andy has remarked frequently over the years that I seem “very natural” with kids (note: screaming kids didn’t count).
Despite these experiences, which all fill me with a glow just thinking/writing about them, the “you’ll lose your life completely” and the “you’ll fuck it up” fears persisted, and continued to manifest as feeling judgmental about the idea of having children.
When I was in Florence this summer, my days knit themselves together with a lot of simplicity. Things were very…slow. It was delicious. I woke up in the mornings and looked out over the stone-tiled roof, listened to the birds chirping and roosters crowing, the lilting Italian conversations I might hear drift up from below. There were no city noise sounds. It was all peace. And I sunk into that peace. I simply sat and watched the world around me, or sometimes I would write in my journal.
A week into my trip, I made contact with some friends of ours who happened to be staying about an hour and a half away, in Anghieri, which is near Arezzo. I went down to Arezzo for the antique market and had lunch with them and with their small son, and then at the last minute they invited me to stay with them at their villa. I had no extra clothes and no toothbrush, but they said that they had a t-shirt I could sleep in and we’d grab a toothbrush at the store.
The twenty-four hours that I spent with them showed me, for the first time, what raising a child could look like if two parents were committed to working together (my own parents’ marriage and subsequent divorce was not an example of this, and neither are some of the other parents I’ve seen). These two parents had established a rhythm with things, they communicated so well by asking questions about what one or the other needed. Their small son was included as part of our meals and conversations, but he was not the sole focal point. I happened to know that the two of them worked very hard on their relationship, both between themselves and with a professional. As a third wheel adult, I felt very easily and simply integrated into their lives, as opposed to the “you just wouldn’t understand” energy I’ve sometimes felt from parents.
One of the things we talked about together were my feelings about being a parent. We talked about some of the difficulties I’ve felt with other parents, about the fears of it changing my life, and about how they made things work.
I’d been having a rough time with jetlag–nearly a week in, and my stomach would still feel queasy. And at one point when I mentioned not feeling so great, the woman looked at me and said, “Are you pregnant?”
And I said, “No.”
And she said: “Are you sure?”
And I said: “I’m sure.”
And–right there–it occurred to me that I was a little…sad (!) that I was not pregnant, that I knew that pregnancy was not a possibility that explained the queasiness. This was, of course, such a strange thought–why would someone be sad they weren’t pregnant, especially someone who was convinced that a kid would change things in so many bad ways, leaving me with no life of my own and then guilt-ridden for not being a better mother?
I left Anghieri and over the next few days and weeks I continued to be slow, to meditate, to think, to write. And one day, out of nowhere, this thought came to me:
“I want to be a mamma.”
On the heels of it was: You DO?
And then, quite certain: Absolutely. I want to be a mamma.
Suddenly, I was laughing and crying at exactly the same time, my hands resting on my lower abdomen, and I was filled with excitement and joy and relief. Of course! Of course I want to be a mamma!
It felt very similar to when, ten years ago, I stopped putting so much energy into insisting on atheism and finally acknowledged that despite an utter lack of provable evidence, and despite the scathing condescension of non-believers, I do believe in a higher power, some Universal life-source energy something that is not polluted with the “God” conception of society but that is all-knowing and all-loving. It was a sense of, “Oh, thank goodness I can just relax now and stop resisting and insisting!”
Resisting = what I felt to be genuinely true for me. Insisting = that I felt something different or that what I felt was wrong.
I felt sort of…nuts with this realization that I wanted to be a mamma. Over the next few days it would keep hitting me again and again: I want to be a mamma. That phrase, exactly–not “mother,” but mamma. And the reaction, again and again, was the same: laughter, and excitement, because–hey!–I get to be a mamma! I get to be a mamma, now! This is so cool! How exciting that I’ve realized this and now I know and I can just acknowledge how I really feel!
I kept checking in with myself–was I sure? Was I sure this was what I wanted? What came up was that I realized that I wanted motherhood and a family, the way I wanted other larger lifelong things, like publishing a book or having more connection with my family.
Spending time with my friends in Italy showed me that there is a way to have a child and not lose oneself entirely. I don’t think it’s easy. But I do think it’s possible. And once I saw how they did things, I started perking up and noticing other families, and how they did things, and then I realized that in fact, in my rush to resist the idea, I had missed a lot of examples of families that work very well. In my resistance/insistence, I had conjured up lots of stories of how awful parenthood had to be, and in fact, I was now seeing a lot of people who seemed to enjoy it, to take the frustrations of it in stride.
But then we get to the “I’ll fuck it up” fear.
And that is where I tell you that my life changed as a result of realizing that I want to be a parent.
For a few years now, I have been seeing a Life Coach named Matthew. I think he is the most wonderful and amazing human being. He gave me a series of daily practices to use as part of our work together. I would do them, but not consistently, and the ones that I most avoided had to do with processing out old angers and hurts. I just did not want to do those practices. I did not want to confront the anger or fear inside.
Having acknowledged that I want to be a mamma, in Italy I began keeping up with those practices every day. There is a fierce lion rawr in me that says: I will not consciously pass on my anger and hurt and pain to my child!
The scope of my life became larger. Suddenly, my life no longer feels entirely about me, anymore. It now feels like it’s about me, and about this child that I want to bring into the world–this child that I have some strange sense of already loving. It’s about wanting to love Andy more deeply, wanting to bridge whatever withholds we have created in our relationship (great as it is, they are of course there), to get to a core intimacy.
All because of this: I am unwilling to consciously damage my child.
For sure, there will be ways that I will unconsciously hurt my child, simply because I’m human and I will make mistakes. But there is a limit, for me, and I see it as this: I know, for instance, that I am someone who can lose her temper easily. It is an old pattern for me to lose my temper when I’m feeling emotionally “leaky” rather than to consciously do process work to get out the hurt/anger/pain. I’m aware that I do this, and thus, to bring a child into that without doing work on it first would be so unfair. Will I lose my temper with my child? At some point. But what I’m speaking into is my unwillingness to continue on with patterns that hurt others, while I sit back and do nothing about them. I’m doing my work now, on a deeper and bigger level, because it would not sit right to me to become a mamma and then continue acting out old patterns without giving my 100% to changing them.
For me, the equation looks like this: Imperfect mom working on healing old wounds = Okay. Imperfect mom who is unwilling to work on healing old wounds = Not Okay. I feel that for me, I must be more conscious than that about my choice to bring a kid into the world. I must.
So now, nearly three months later, life feels very different. My pivot point has shifted.
I am not pregnant and do not intend to be at any time soon. At the same time that I want to have consciousness around my habits re: relationships with others, I want to be conscious of the fact that I do want to travel for a year in 2010, and I do need time to work on changing old patterns, and I do have creative goals that, objectively speaking, will be more easily accomplished while I am without child. There are lots of other factors that go into this, and the timing, for one thing, is a big one.
And, by the way, I shared all of this with Andy–who was shocked by the turn around, but who is happy because he has always envisioned himself as a father one day.
I now realize that all of my hostility and judgment was really just a reaction to how badly I wanted something yet how awful I felt about telling myself that I couldn’t have it, wanting to love THAT BIG yet being afraid that I would not really have that chance.
And so it is. My daily life changes little–I am still me, still following the same path of working on me, but noticing that I have fewer excuses. When resistance to doing my tools/practices comes up, I notice that just thinking for even a second of HOW BIG I want to love my family one day is enough to get me moving. It’s as if someone said to me if I apply myself for the next two or three years, at the end of it I’ll get a million bazillion dollars, and all I have to do is just put forth my very best effort.
I never thought the day would come when having a family would be the type of thing I’d equate with getting a million bazillion dollars.
I’m so happy that it has. It feels like a wider and truer opening up into who I am.
And, by the way, I want to say that I don’t believe that my life as a mother will be any more or less valid than the lives of those who decide not to have kids. I still support, and will always support, someone’s choice not to have children. As Elizabeth Gilbert said in a talk she gave in San Francisco last year, “The world needs lots of us Aunties.” I love that thought of creating a community, a family, that transcends bloodlines and ropes all different choices and paths into a circle of inclusion.