March 30th, 2010
less impact woman
So. There’s this thing that’s been brewing around in the back of my wee ole noggin.
The thing that has been brewing looks something like this: Last year, I started eating meat again. It was sort of an accident. Kind of. It was an accident that looked like Andy eating an In n’ Out Burger hamburger, and me having a bite, and that burger was, you know, SO GOOD, so I got a whole one. For the twenty-four hour period following eating that hamburger, I had so much energy. It was such a noticeable amount of energy that I went, “Hmmmm. Maybe I’m supposed to be a meat-eater.”
So I started eating meat again. I noticed that I had more energy. I had been a vegetarian for 14 years, and then switched to a raw foods diet, in the hopes of counteracting the near constant tiredness, headaches, and colds that I’d been getting. The raw foods diet certainly does work, in my opinion, but good heavens if I could keep that up. Especially come winter time–who wants to hunker down on a cold night with a…spinach salad?
I am a voracious reader and, in the past year and mostly thanks to instant downloads on Netflix, a voracious documentary watcher. I read and then saw the movie Fast Food Nation. I also watched Food, Inc. I’m almost finished with John Robbins’ Diet for a New America. I’m a total Michael Pollan fan. I’ve watched and/or read a whole host of other documentaries in the past year, and again and again I keep coming to a conclusion, one that has a core basis in my sense of personal integrity and what I am willing to participate in, that factory farming is just not at all good for the planet. Stemming from that I have been questioning eating meat, how I make purchasing decisions around food, and my overall environmental impact.
I have not done anything about what I’ve been questioning, for one simple reason: I have not been ready.
Now, I’m ready.
Over the past weekend, I watched the documentary No Impact Man. In essence, what I take away from the film are a few things. One, that I am educated about the issues and have been content to sit back and let my awareness of them be enough (sometimes, awareness is its own contribution; for my own personal sense of integrity on the issue of environmental impact, it does not feel like the case). Two, if a couple with a small child living in New York City in a tiny apartment can completely cut out their environmental impacts for a year and eat in season, then I, living in a house with no child to take care of, living in the state of California, mecca of the farmer’s market and the longest growing season in the country, can make some shifts myself.
Then the essential question becomes: What shifts to make? There are a few that I know I won’t be making. One is giving up my car. San Francisco is home of what I call “shitty and inconsistent public transportation charging an arm and a leg while trying to pretend it comes even remotely close to the subway systems of New York City, Chicago, London, etc.” There is totally a market here for a widespread and efficient public transit system–tons of people who would happily give up their cars–and yet there is not the willingness to build it or make it cost-effective. It is cheaper for me to drive my car over the Bay Bridge, even paying tolls and gas, than it is for me to take the BART train, and even if I were to take BART, I’d still have to drive my car to a station, anyway (where I’d then have to pay even more money to park in a station lot, or spend 15-30 minutes burning gas circling to find a parking spot in a residential neighborhood).
So, no giving up the car.
There are other things that I know people around here do, like not turn on the heat in the winter because it really doesn’t get all that cold. Hmmmm. Near the top of the list of things I dislike, being cold is one of them. So, the heat will stay. And for sure, I don’t see myself giving up toilet paper or electricity, like No Impact Man.
But I have always been moved by the saying that “No one can do everything, but everyone can do something.”
So I’m preparing to experiment with two things: moving back into vegetarianism and possibly even veganism, and eliminating all food packaging from my life.
I say “experiment” because I know that one of the quickest ways to kill enthusiasm for an idea is to make it something that I “have to” do. Additionally, while I have a theory that the reason I felt sick so often when I was a vegetarian has more to do with eating bowls of cereal and calling it a “vegetarian diet,” I’m also aware that I did feel an immediate and substantial benefit from eating meat, and that is not to be overlooked. One of the reasons I’m really impressed with John Robbins’ book is that he specifically states that a.) he does not believe that one should be judged for their food choices, and b.) that yes, there are some people for whom a vegetarian diet does not work. Earlier this year, I talked to some vegans about their choices and one vegan nutritionist even said that some people’s bodies don’t produce enough carnitine, though it’s unknown why, and that this can be supplemented. Ultimately, even continuing to eat meat won’t really be too much of a problem–I am lucky enough to live near a place that has a local butcher, and that butcher buys only from farms where animals are treated well, fed organic and no-hormone diets, etc. So if I don’t stick with being a vegan, it’s great to know that I have other options.
Shift two that I will be experimenting with is moving into eliminating all packaging from my food purchases. I’ll start with eliminating plastic (the worst thing to use for anything, because it takes the most chemicals to make and is hardest to recycle), and then move towards eliminating all packaging. Perhaps this shift is the one I’m most excited about, in part because most of the foods I eat (rice, quinoa, cereals, etc.) are things that I can easily find in bulk grain bins and it’s a shift that I can feel proud of while really only being of minor inconvenience. Currently, I buy cereal by the box; I can switch to getting it from a bulk bin. Currently, I buy rice by the bag; I can switch to getting it from a bulk bin. It’s a matter of convenience, and I have one set of plastic bags that I can use for transport between the store and my home, and simply re-use those bags each time that I go to the store. Also, I’ll just make it a point of going to any one of the gadzillion farmer’s markets around here and this will enable me to eat seasonally and support local farm producers, which I feel better about than supporting factory farming.
Another step? Spending this past Sunday in the back yard, planting a vegetable garden! I’m excited about this one in particular, though I’m holding a space of low expectations because who knows whether or not raccoons, birds, or bugs will get my first crop. I’m notorious for killing houseplants, so we’ll see how it goes with my little vegetable plot!
So–let’s say I’m not becoming a “no impact man” so much as I’m being a “less impact woman.” In measurable results, I can say that Andy and I currently produce one and a half trash cans full (13 gallon trash cans) per week of recyclable material. Andy’s along for the ride at the moment, so if we were to cut down our packaging use to zero, one could estimate that we’d save approximately 1,1014 gallons of recyclable material each year. Is it significant? Nah. But is it kind of cool? Absolutely!
The only part of this that I’m not looking forward to? Justifying decisions. Blech. The one thing I was happy to leave behind when I started eating meat again was dealing with people who assume that my food choices were an inherent judgement of their own, or the people who insisted that plant-based diets were dangerous, etc. At the end of the day, though, I know that I am “behind” my choices and so ultimately, it’s okay if others disagree. I’m committed to feeling good about my choices, not changing others’. I also like what Stacy writes about that, here.
I’m so curious to hear about other ways that you personally step into “no one can do everything, but everyone can do something.” And of all the things I’ve brainstormed for alternatives to packaging, I’ve found solutions so far for everything but two: chocolate and soymillk. Any idea where I can get my hands on chocolate that isn’t packaged? Any idea where I could do a bottle deposit system for soymilk? Hmmmm.








March 30th, 2010 at 4:31 pm
We gave up our car (in a very crap public transportation city) almost 9 years ago. There are benefits to this that are unimaginable until you do it. We do a plethora of other things that I won’t go into.
I was a veg for about ten years and went back to eating meat for energy and health reasons.
I always wonder why people leap so quickly to the vegan thing, rather than simply switching their meat and dairy to local, humane, healthy sources. It’s not easy, but supporting the farmers who do this RIGHT is a good thing. It’s not cheap, but then that naturally decreases proportions to more proper amounts.
Just curious…
March 30th, 2010 at 4:48 pm
I notice that when I read “I always wonder why people leap so quickly to the vegan thing, rather than simply switching their meat and dairy to local, humane, healthy sources,” the sentence lands on me as carrying some judgement. Is there any of that there, or am I making up a Story?
To answer, I’m really seeing everything as a “see how this looks” experiment. I don’t know that I’ll be stepping back into vegetarianism, if that will work for me, or if being a vegan will work for me. I’m considering a vegan diet because of the immense amount of energy that goes into raising, feeding, and caring for animals (even under humane conditions) when those resources could be otherwise diverted, as well as the CO2 impact of cattle in particular. I’ve also been considering the moral issues surrounding vegan eating–For instance, I wouldn’t eat my cat. I’m experimenting with questioning what value difference (other than a socially conditioned one that I’ve been taught) there is between cats or pigs or cows or dogs. I’m still back and forth a lot on that question!
Finally, high cholesterol runs in my family. This past year, my 25 year old sister who eats a diet that contains meat but that is what I would call reasonably healthy was diagnosed with high cholesterol. I find myself wondering if I would be in the same boat, if not for the years of vegetarianism, and if meat eating will put me on the road to the same conditions if I’m not careful.
How did you transition into giving up your car, even in a city with poor public transit? I’m so curious about this; the idea of it seems almost insurmountable in this moment. And I’d also love to hear about the other things that you do!
March 31st, 2010 at 12:54 pm
Have you read John’s newer book on food called Food Revolution http://www.foodrevolution.org ?
March 31st, 2010 at 1:15 pm
I haven’t, but I think it’s next on my list!
March 31st, 2010 at 1:17 pm
I’ve thought a lot about this subject. I really respect the approach of Hugh Fearnley Whittingstall http://www.rivercottage.net/Page~59/Hugh.aspx – I’m not sure if he’s made it across the Atlantic yet, but he advocates farming animals in a conscious, ethical and compassionate way. Part of his philosophy is to respect the animal, provide it with a comfortable and happy life and then utlise every part of it once it has given its life to us. That, to me, sounds like an ok deal.
Because of this approach I always now buy only organic, ethically reared meat. If I can’t find this (which isn’t always possible where I live) then I eat vegetarian food. I also try to make meals out of the cheaper cuts of meat (beef shin, making soup stock from chicken bones etc) as the local farmer’s markets usually have these for sale, and it is my way of appreciating the sacrifice the animal has made.
I tried vegetarianism for a while but found myself having to buy meat anyway to feed my pet cats (as cats are obligate carnivores) and it just seemed incongruous that I could buy meat for them but not for me.
Growing your own veg sounds great!! I’m definitely doing the same this year – just waiting for the weather to get a bit better! Hugh FW is behind a programme called Landshare, where people with land can lend it to people who want to grow their own veg or keep some livestock. Great idea!
April 1st, 2010 at 4:33 am
I think that giving up your car is more about giving up the idea of convenience. instead planning your life around not having it. I have to say that being a non driver I plan my life ie bought my flat somwerhere which has good public transport – I go on holiday by train ! In our city there is someing called a car club which you can join.I don’t because I can’t drive.
There are other choices like I try to buy fairtrade coffee and sugar – I made the switch about 10 years ago and I’m hoping that my consitent buying of this product has made a difference. I chose lamb over other meats as its as near to organic and free range in the uk without the certification. I buy organic free range eggs. I buy more expensive food but drink less wine. I buy fewer clothes but try not to buy cheap ones. I have my shoulds of course … like I’d like to buy more organic (I currently get an organic box delivery twice a month) and I have problems with flying to see my grandmother in australia every few years but the bus takes 3 months and costs £4000! I’d lvoe to take the bus to oz…
I worry that I should be growing my food turning my garden into an allotment.
April 2nd, 2010 at 6:07 am
I gave up my car recently because I lived in the inner city and never used it. Now I’ve moved to the outer suburbs and have to rely on crap public transport. Still I figure I’d never drive into work in the city anyway because of the stress involved in peak hour driving. Even with a car, I’d only drive if there was no other workable alternative. Ideally I’d like to get confident enough to ride my bike as my main transport.
I guess the down side is that without a car, it become really difficult to do those other things like going to farmer’s markets etc. In the end, you do what you can and I think if you know that you are always trying to less impactful (is that even a word) all the time, then that’s enough.
April 2nd, 2010 at 12:10 pm
No. No judgment. Though the judgment I have incurred going away from vegetarianism has been close to wrathful. I have always asserted — esp. when I was veg — that food choices are completely personal and wrapped up in a million factors.
I really, really am just totally curious about this. It reminds me of my own tendency toward all or nothing sorts of thinking.
There was no transition, actually, with the no car lifestyle. Like I said — all or nothin’ for this chick.
One day we had it; the next day we didn’t. Then we dealt with that.